Mutual Funds vs Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)

May 14, 2019

Mutual Funds vs Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)


We’re four months into 2019 and we’ve seen a sharp increase in the major stock market indices with the Dow +13.45% and the S&P 500 +16.56% as of the end of April. Participating in this type of broad-based growth as an investor can be accomplished in a handful of ways - primarily with mutual funds and exchange traded funds (ETFs). There are distinct differences between these two investment products - and it’s not uncommon for us to receive questions on the details of how they work.


Both types of investment products - ETFs and Mutual Funds - were created from the concept of pooled fund investing. Pooled funds bundle securities (stocks, bonds..etc) together to offer investors the benefit of diversification. Typically, a mutual fund or ETF will hold anywhere from 100 to 3,000 different individual securities within the fund. Diversification can help an investor manage risk and reduce volatility associated with individual stocks and bonds. When the value of a single stock or bond drops, it has a smaller effect on the value of a diversified investment than it would if you held the stock or bond individually. Mutual Funds became available in 1924 while ETFs first began trading in 1993 and were originally created to track an index such as the S&P 500. 


While both were founded on the same basic concept of diversification, they are very different in many respects. One major difference is that mutual funds trade through the mutual fund company or broker at the end of a trading day while an ETF trades on an exchange and is available to trade at any point during the trading day. Mutual funds typically have higher expense ratios compared to ETFs and can carry an up-front sales load ranging from 3.75% to 5.75% if a Class-A share. Another drawback of mutual funds is the periodic payout of capital gains distributions to the investors causing greater tax implications if held outside an IRA or 401(k). Mutual funds offer more actively-managed portfolios than ETFs since ETFs often track an index, however actively-managed ETFs are becoming more common. 


Annual Organic Growth Rate of Mutual Funds vs. ETFs 2008 through 2018 - Morningstar, Inc.


While ETFs carry some distinct advantages, mutual funds still made up about 80% of the $18 Trillion in total assets held between ETFs and mutual funds at the end of 2017. Why is this? First, they have been around much longer but they’re still the primary offering in most corporate retirement plans, such as 401(k) and 403(b) plans. ETFs experienced an organic growth rate of 16.5% per year over a 10-year period spreading from 2008 through 2017 while mutual funds grew at a 2% clip. Organic growth rate does not factor in investment performance but reflects where investors are putting their new investment dollars. As investments in ETFs (with firms such as BlackRock and Vanguard) continue to increase, investors benefit from lower expense ratios.   In many cases, mutual fund expenses are being reduced in an attempt to be more competitive with ETFs. We expect to see a continued shift from the use of mutual funds to ETFs due to the numerous advantages of ETFs and the focus on lower investment costs.

February 4, 2025
Deepseek and its Low Cost Claims The final week of January was a whirlwind for the stock market, with tech stocks taking center stage. On Monday, the Nasdaq saw its sharpest decline in over a month following news from China about DeepSeek, a ChatGPT competitor. NVIDIA, a dominant force in AI infrastructure, faced a staggering setback, losing nearly $600 billion in market value - the largest single-day dollar loss in U.S. stock market history. DeepSeek claims to operate at a fraction of the cost of U.S. competitors, requiring less processing memory to train and run. While the long-term implications remain uncertain, this development introduces increased volatility and uncertainty in the near term. Earnings Sensitivity Last week also brought earnings reports from four of the Magnificent Seven, along with other key U.S. companies. So far, 77% of S&P 500 companies that have reported Q4 2024 earnings have exceeded expectations, while 63% have surpassed revenue estimates (FACTSET). Historically, positive earnings surprises have led to modest stock price increases, while negative surprises resulted in declines. However, recent quarters have shown heightened market sensitivity to earnings results. For example, IBM exceeded expectations and issued a strong outlook, leading to a 13% one-day gain. Conversely, Lockheed Martin fell 9% after reporting lower-than-expected revenue and offering cautious guidance. Recently, S&P 500 companies that beat both sales and earnings expectations saw an average stock price gain of 3.6% post-announcement, well above the five-year average of 0.9%. Meanwhile, companies that missed estimates saw an average 5% decline, compared to the historical average of 3.1%. Market Concentration With the S&P 500 trading at above-average earnings multiples, investors are watching earnings reports closely. All 11 sectors of the index are expected to see earnings growth in 2024. Why does this matter? The Magnificent Seven currently make up 30% of the S&P 500’s value and accounted for 50% of the index’s gains in 2024. To sustain market growth, the remaining 493 companies will need to contribute more significantly. While the market has reached new highs over the past two years, those gains have been driven by a small group of companies. For context, the only other time such a limited number of stocks dominated performance over a two-year period was during the late-90s dot-com bubble. This narrow market leadership presents a double-edged sword. On one hand, it raises concerns about whether a handful of companies can continue to outperform. On the other, it creates an opportunity for broader market participation, with the rest of the S&P 500 looking more attractive from a valuation and diversification perspective. Periods of concentrated market leadership often lead to increased volatility as investors weigh sticking with what has worked - the Magnificent Seven - versus diversifying to reduce risk. The S&P 500 is currently top-heavy, with its 10 largest companies accounting for 30% of the index. January managed to post gains, but not without some turbulence. We expect market volatility to rise in 2025, compared to the relative calm of the past two years. Last but not Least - Tariffs Additionally, tariffs have recently moved to the forefront. While new tariffs on Mexico and Canada were announced and then delayed by a month, the U.S. moved forward with tariffs on China. The uncertainty surrounding potential tariff impacts adds another layer of market unpredictability. In summary, markets face increasing uncertainty from new AI competition, earnings sensitivity, narrow leadership, and trade policy developments. While diversification may not have been "in style" in recent years, it remains a valuable tool for managing volatility. As always, investors should maintain a long-term perspective and avoid getting caught up in short-term market swings. If you have questions or concerns about your individual situation, please don’t hesitate to contact us.
July 15, 2024
Over the past few years, the breakdown of the S&P 500 has changed drastically. Although the visual is over a year old, today Nvidia...
Buyback surge
June 28, 2024
It occurs when a company uses excess cash or debt to purchase its own shares. Buybacks are popular because they reduce the number of shares ...
April 8, 2024
In recent weeks, we’ve been asked several times about how to invest given the significant climb in the stock market over the last 5 months. Let’s look back at the recent quarter performance as well as the overall market performance since the October 2023 lows…
February 2, 2024
While most know “Facebook” by its given name, it trades as a stock under the name “Meta”. Years after changing its corporate name to Meta, it still resonates as Facebook to us and likely most of you reading this post.
December 16, 2023
Looking back on our previous post about historical 4th quarter performance, after October it looked like we were staring down a 4th quarter with negative returns.
October 17, 2023
As we enter the early stages of the fourth quarter of the year, the month of September reared its ugly head again in the markets.
August 28, 2023
Trying to avoid having a “short-term memory” when it comes to investing isn’t always easy. Look at last year (2022) - as uncertainty filled the markets...
May 26, 2023
As the Debt Ceiling deadline approaches, we thought it would be timely to discuss what this means and potential implications to the economy and the financial markets.
March 9, 2023
A client shared a great article on the power of dividend investing, worth a read...
More Posts
Share by: